The First Call Inbox

Forgiveness, feel or traditional lofts? What readers seek in irons

From forged heads and zero offset to perimeter-weighted distance, The First Call readers share the key features and fitting philosophies that guide their iron purchases.

Question of the week [Nov. 9-15]: What characteristics do you look for when buying a set of irons?

The First Call Inbox archives | View
———————

Dave Curley | Las Vegas, NV
Ability to flight the ball and control trajectory.
—————

Nick Potts | Granville, OH
I still prefer a traditional look at address. I like a bit of offset, though not too much, and I steer away from oversized heads. These days, I play some form of cavity back or perimeter-weighted iron rather than solid blades, and I prefer a chrome finish over buffed or black designs.

I also favor traditional lofts for distance consistency rather than modern strong lofts that let some of my buddies brag at the bar about hitting a 209-yard 7-iron. Similarly, I stick to traditional bounce angles and avoid soles so wide you could hit a 5-iron out of a bunker. Overall, my irons have to set up pleasingly to the eye and deliver a soft feel at impact. It is a great time to be a golfer, given all the choices in design and technology.
—————

Dennis Brissette | Heathrow, FL
Eye appeal, head shape, and degree of offset.
—————

Reid Farrill | Toronto, Ontario
Online reviews and independent tests are critically important to me, as they help narrow the field down to a few specific brands and models. Like most golfers, I play a perimeter-weighted iron — ideally forged rather than cast. Despite my advancing age, steel shafts remain my preference over graphite. Hybrids and rescue clubs are gradually reducing the number of irons in my bag; next season, my iron set will run from 6-iron through pitching wedge and sand wedge.

Thomas Reed | Springfield, TN
I want irons that look good at address, feel solid at impact, and deliver consistent accuracy when struck well.

Norman Arychuk | Toronto, Ontario
As a 15-handicapper, I look for forgiveness, distance, a comfortable look behind the ball, and overall build quality.
—————

Jim Campbell | Seattle, WA
Feel and consistency.
—————

Tyler Peek | Leland, NC
Swing feel and forgiveness.
—————

Richard Eherenman | Annapolis, MD
Feel and overall head weight.
—————

Gregory W. Miller | Savannah, GA
Forgiveness.
—————

Donn Rutkoff | Oceanside, CA
Accuracy and tight dispersion.
—————

Brent Myers | Kidron, OH
Four things:

  1. A manufacturer that does not also make golf balls.
  2. Appearance at address.
  3. Feel at impact.
  4. Ball trajectory.

John Cathey | Tualatin, OR
Forgiveness and appearance.
—————

Shaun J. Bezilla | Harbor Springs, MI
Good looks and overall playability.
—————

Barry Duckworth | Knoxville, TN
I have been custom-fitted for my last four sets of irons over the past 12 years. I prefer traditional looks with zero offset,and I need help getting the ball airborne since I naturally hit a low ball flight, alongside plenty of forgiveness. Beyond the pitching wedge, I get fitted separately for 50-, 56- and 58-degree wedges — not necessarily from the same brand as my irons. My 58-degree has very low bounce (currently 8 degrees) to handle tight lies around the green.
—————

Randy Bickle | Canton, MI
Workability and style.
—————

Les Shirey | Cary, NC
Ball flight and feel.
—————

Brian Stifora | Lake Havasu City, AZ
Forged construction, moderate forgiveness, and a players-iron profile.
—————

Paul Martin | Interlochen, MI
A leading edge that sits flush with the turf, a lie angle that isn't too upright, and a moderate clubface area with a generous sweet spot.
—————

Steve Moore | Birmingham, AL
Soft feel, high launch, and distance — even if they require stronger lofts to achieve that yardage — along with a look behind the ball that inspires confidence at address.
—————

The First Call invites reader comment. Write to editor Stuart Hall at shall@buffalogroupe.com. If your comment is selected for publication, we will not publish your email address. We reserve the right to edit for clarity and brevity.

Front: A bag featuring Titleist irons, displayed at the BMW International.
Photo: David Lloyd / Golffile


Share